Textual notes
Abbreviations,
Bibliography
In Paul's first letter to the Corinthians he tackles a number of specific problems in the church. One of these problems is immorality. In chapters 5 and 6 Paul deals with this issue. He begins by confronting a particular situation where someone in the church has married their "fathers wife." Paul tells the church that they should deal with this problem, that they should pass judgement on it. This leads him to discuss the problem of lawsuits between members of the church. They should deal with such disputes within the church itself. Church members need to deal with these matters in the knowledge that evil-livers "will not inherit the kingdom of God." Returning again to sexual immorality, Paul raises the issue of church members visiting prostitutes.
Dealing with ethics in the Gentile churches was no easy task for Paul. On the one hand he had to steer Gentile believers away from the slavery of the law, but on the other hand, he had to counsel those believers who were allowing their Christian freedom to enslave them again to sin. It was a constant battle to stop believers returning to the law as a means of restraining sin and progressing holiness to facilitate the blessings of the covenant. Paul knew well enough that a return to law-righteousness not only promoted disobedience, but also undermined salvation. A believer's progression toward Christ-likeness, as well as their possession of Christ-likeness, is always a matter of grace appropriated through faith. It is "Christ in us" that enables us to be what we are. Yet, in dealing with the Corinthians it was the slavery to sin problem that confronted Paul. Interestingly, it is quite possible that those he speaks against might have been influenced by his teaching on justification by faith apart from works of the law. That is, he may be speaking against those who have misunderstood the concept of "freedom" in Christ. His legalist brothers had always warned him that to remove the law from a believer is to invite libertarianism - anything goes. The problem in Corinth may well be this very problem.
There are other possible scenarios for the Corinthian libertarianism. The influence of Platonic thought is one of the more popular. In Platonic thought, flesh is separated from spirit. One is of this earth and is destined for oblivion; the other is of God and is destined for eternity. Such a view can also promote an "anything goes" mentality. The Corinthians were certainly into the "spiritual" and their emphasis of the spiritual self might have left them open to a disregard for the physical self. Just as it is possible for us to subject ourselves to the law and end up undermining our salvation, so it is possible to subject ourselves to sin and similarly undermine our salvation.
For some reason or other believers tend toward Platonic dualism - the body is matter and is to be cast off; the soul is of God and is to be preserved. In popular theology it comes down to the body of the dead still in the grave, but the soul alive in heaven. Resurrection is often seen as a spiritual thing which concerns the soul, the real self, separate from the body which is something to be cast off. This heresy results in two different approaches. The first approach is libertarianism. Seeing the body is something to be cast off in death, then it doesn't matter what we do with it. We might as well satisfy its appetites, for then we won't get distracted from the more important spiritual issues of life. The second approach is asceticism. Seeing the body is something to be cast off in death, then it is best now to subdue its control over us and so allow us to live free from its constraints and thus accentuate the spiritual self.
How then does Paul confront this libertarian problem? He focuses on sound teaching - Spirit filled truth. Walking in the Spirit comes about by hearing the leading of the Spirit. It is this leading, through the ministry of the Apostles, Prophets, Teachers and Pastors, which inevitably builds us "up until we all reach unity in the faith and in the knowledge of the Son of God and become mature, attaining to the whole measure of the fullness of Christ", Eph.4:11-13. So, Paul gives the Corinthians sound teaching, and in the power of the Spirit, this truth will set them free. Those who are in Christ will hear Christ and as Christ is in them, he will change them into his own image.
v12
Given that the "everything is permissible" is probably a libertine slogan, quotation marks should be added with an added introduction, "some of you say", CEV.
exestin (ex-eimi) "is permissible" - it is possible, right. "All things are lawful", NRSV etc., is misleading since the slogan claims authority to act independently of any law or convention, so "I am free to do anything", Thiselton, Zerwick...
sumferei (sumferw) "is beneficial" - is better, an advantage, helpful. "Not everything is profitable or expedient for the Christian life", Bruce.
ouk egw exousiasqhsomai (exousiazw) fut. pas. "I will not be mastered" - I will not be enslaved, ruled over, bound as by a yoke. Unfettered liberty enslaves. "I will not allow anything to get the mastery over me", Bruce.
v13
Another slogan requiring inverted comers, although the quote probably includes "and God will do away with both of them", Barrett, Thiselton.... Obviously the slogan includes all bodily functions, particularly sex. Paul would generally agree on the food issue, but even here it is necessary to be all things to all men, eg. the faith of a Jewish believer can be easily damaged if we were to chew on a pork spare rib in front of them. Illicit sex may be a bodily function, but in reality it involves the whole person and so affects the whole person. A Platonic dualism, where the physical and spiritual are independent and where the physical is a lower order of little concern, does not align with the Biblical view of a person as an integrated being of both body and soul. The body is even raised and transformed on the day of Christ's return. The sense is improved with an introduction; "you also say", CEV.
th/ koilia/ "for the stomach" - digestive system. "Food is for digestion."
th porneia/ (a) "sexual immorality" - fornication. The context implies "consorting with prostitutes." The RSV "immorality" is not specific enough.
tw/ kuriw/ (oV) dat. "for the Lord" - The dative is either taking an instrumental sense", "you should use your body to serve the Lord", TH; or a local sense, "the body belongs to the Lord as the Lord belongs to the body", Barrett. "Belong" is best, although probably more in the sense of "incorporated with", "part of" and therefore "belonging to."
v14
hgeiren (egeirw) aor. "raised" - raised up. Christ is raised, not rises; he is the object or the act.
exegerei, exhgeiren, exegeirei (exegeirw) fut. "he will raise" - [and also] he will raise up [us through the power of him]. As well as future, there are past and present variants. The past tense, being the less probable reading and therefore possibly original, actually helps make Paul's argument, namely, that it would be quite unnatural for a person who has been raised with Christ and empowered to live for him (in a spiritual sense), to then go and visit prostitutes; "and he raised us also by his power", cf. NJB margin.
v15
melh (oV) "members" - body parts. Since we are raised with Christ, we are one with Christ. Our very being is united to Christ. "Your bodies are parts of the body of Christ", CEV; "limbs and organs", REB.
araV (airw) aor. part. "take" - having taken away, carried off, snatched, wrenched. The participle is adverbial, possibly consecutive, "since, therefore, I have taken the members of Christ shall I make them members of a prostitute?"
poihsw (poiew) aor. subj. / fut. "shall I .... unite" - should/shall I make. Deliberative subjunctive, or a plain future indicative. Am I then going to / shall I "take the limbs which rightly belong to Christ and make them limbs which belong to a prostitute?", Barclay.
mh genoito aor. mid. opt. "Never!" - may it not happen. Optative expressing a wish; "perish the thought", "God forbid", AV.
v16
h "-" - or. Variant, probably not original.
ouk oidate (oida) perf. "do you not know?" - Rhetorical question with the sense "aren't you aware?"; "Don't you realize that when a man joins himself to a prostitute he makes with her a physical unity?", Phillips.
oJ kollwmenoV (kollaw) pres. pas. part. "he who unites himself" - the one joining himself. Participle as a substantive. Obviously intended, "has sexual relations with", TH.
eJn swma estin "is one with her in body" - one body is. "Becomes physically one with her", REB, Barclay ..., although "physical" is probably going beyond what Paul means. The term "one body" reflects Genesis 2:24, "one flesh". The union he is referring to is surely psychosomatic. Sexual union "is an act which, by reason of its very nature, engages and expresses the whole personality in such a way as to constitute a unique mode of self-disclosure and self-commitment", D.S. Bailey.
v17
eJn pneuma (a atoV) "one with him in spirit" - one spirit. "Paul is probably referring to the work of the Spirit, whereby through the one Spirit the believer's `spirit' has been joined indissolubly with Christ", Fee.
v18
feugete (feugw) imp. "flee from" - run away from. "Flee" can be expressed in the terms of "avoid / keep away from"; "avoid sexual looseness like the plague", Phillips.
thn porneian (a) "sexual immorality" - As noted above, the word primarily concerns dealings with prostitutes, so Phillips' "sexual looseness" is highly misleading. Barclay's specific "fornication" is more to the point, thus removing this verse from the arsenal of those who include, for example masturbation, etc. under the catch-all of "sexual immorality."
"other" - Not found in the Greek text. Added for meaning and found in most translations. There is a good possibility that we have here the beginning of a new paragraph and that Paul is putting up another Corinthian slogan to demolish; "every sin that a person commits is outside the body", NRSV. If a quote, inverted comers need to be added. The slogan would imply that sin does not affect the self ("body"). Paul would argue that all sin affects the self, and when it comes to visiting prostitutes, any fool can see that it affects the self.
anqrwpoV (oV) "a man" - In the sense of "human"; "all other sins that people may commit", NJB.
ektoV tou swmatoV "outside his body" - outside the self. Of course, taken as a slogan, it is not true, although it is usually argued that it is true, ie. sexual sins are more serious than other sins, see below.
eiV "against" - to, into, for. Fornication turns back on and "into" the self, "attacks / invades." This sin leaves the psychological imprint of the prostitute, which in turn, tares the self away from the Lord. The two unions are mutually exclusive. Paul is probably not arguing that fornication, unlike all other sin, damages the self, rather that it can be easily argued (if not demonstrated) that fornication damages the self, as does all sin. Paul is not implying that fornication is a greater sin than say the exploitation of the poor through wealth or power. It is interesting to note how this verse has helped influence the view that sexual sin is more serious than other sins, which view is reinforced in modern translations by the addition of "other", eg., "it is not possible to mention anything worse than fornication", Chrysostom.
v19
Punctuation. The verse is probably a single sentence, " ....... and that you are not your own?", NAB.
naoV (oV) "a temple" - a sanctuary. Commonly understood as the dwelling place of God; "the sanctuary of the Holy Spirit", Bruce. Note that Paul later develops the idea of the Holy Spirit resident in "the body of Christ", ie. the church. Here the body is the individual self of a believer, and that self is a sanctuary, a set-apart place to commune with the divine.
en "who is in [you]" - in, with, by. This preposition can be read numerous ways: "within you", NRSV; "in you", TEV; "where the Holy Spirit lives", CEV; "your body is a temple of the indwelling Holy Spirit", REB. Best understood in the sense of "in union with", reflecting a relational idea rather than an actual indwelling (a continuation of the "one flesh" idea, of which sex is a visible expression of the "cleaving" in marriage.)
v20
hgorasqhte (agorazw) aor. pas. "you were bought" - you were purchased. The only time Paul uses this word to describe our redemption.
timhV (h) "at a price" - price, amount, cost. The genitive producing "for a price", "at a price", or "with a price," The "price" is obviously Christ's sacrifice, his faithfulness on our behalf ("faith of Christ"), cf. Rom.3:24, Eph.1:7.
kai en tw/ pneumati uJmwn atina esti tou qeou "-" - and in your spirit, which are God's. Variant from the Byzantine text. Lightfoot suggests it is a versicle response to "glorify God in your body" which somehow got attached to the text.