Lectionary Bible Studies and Sermons



Romans

Ingrafted Gentile branches. 11:11-24

[Seed logo] Introduction
      In chapter 11, Paul declares that God has not cast off his historic people, even though it may seem that way. God has saved a remnant according to the election of grace, v1-10, and his present rejection of most of Israel is certainly not permanent, v11-24. Paul believes that his own Gentile mission will prod many of his countryman to accept Jesus as the messiah. A remnant has already believed, and the day will come when a representative majority of Israel will receive Jesus. In the meantime, Gentile believers should not feel themselves superior to unbelieving Jews. It was only through the unbelief of Israel that the Gentiles (the "wild olive shoot") were ingrafted into the kingdom.

The passage
      v11. The present unbelief of Israel may seem permanent, but it is not so. Israel's unbelief serves as an instrument of salvation for the Gentiles, which salvation will inturn prompt Israel to look to Jesus as the long-awaited messiah.
      v12. Israel's unbelief brought blessing to the Gentiles. Israel's belief will bring even greater blessings to all mankind.
      v13-14. Paul now addresses the Gentile members of the Roman church. It may seem to them that he has abandoned his fellow countrymen, but in reality, Paul believes that his Gentile mission will provoke many Jews to accept Jesus.
      v15. Israel's rejection of Jesus the messiah goes hand-in-hand with God's rejection of Israel, yet, Israel's rejection of Jesus, culminating in his death, achieves the reconciliation of the world to God. Israel's final acceptance of Jesus will complete that reconciliation, serving as the culmination of all things in the realization of the kingdom of heaven.
      v16. Israel remains "holy" (sacred) in God's sight, because the whole is purified by the holiness of the "firstfruit", the "root" - the sanctified remnant according to grace. This remnant is most likely the Jewish believers who are holy through their identification with Jesus, who is himself the true remnant of Israel. Some commentators argue that the "root" is Abraham, or even the Patriarchs. Either way, Abraham's descendents are special to God.
      v17-18. Paul now develops an agricultural metaphor (v17-24) which is actually "contrary to nature". Good fruiting stock is grafted to vigorous wild root stock, not visa versa. Yet, the point is simple enough. The Gentiles are spiritually blessed because of their incorporation into God's chosen people, so therefore they should not "boast" (triumph) over Israel, nor over the unbelieving "branches" broken out of the tree.
      v19-21. It is true that God has rejected unbelieving Israel, and that Gentile believers now stand in Israel's place, but this is not of works, but by grace through faith. So, there is no ground for pride (arrogance, haughtiness). If God didn't spare Israel's unbelief, neither will he spare Gentile unbelief. Be warned.
      v22. God cannot be taken for granted; He is both hard and merciful. At the present moment the Gentiles have sought his mercy and have received it. If they reject that mercy, as Israel has, they too will be "cut off".
      v23. God's grace, his generous kindness and love, is available to all who seek it. God is willing and able to extend his mercy to Israel again.
      v24. If God is able to gather Gentiles into the kingdom, then he is well able to regather Israel into the kingdom.

The "Christ killers"
      Haldane writes of this passage, "The Jewish nation was God's olive tree. They were all the people of God in a typical sense, and the greater part of God's true people had been chosen out of them; but now, by their unbelief, some of the branches were broken off from the tree....... And among, or rather instead of, those that were broken off, the Gentiles, who were a wild olive, having had no place in the good olive tree, are now made the children of Abraham by faith in Christ Jesus, Gal.3:26-29. They were grafted into the good olive tree, whose root Abraham was, and were made partakers of his distinguished privileges.... Whenever Gentile Christians feel a disposition to boast with respect to the Jews, let them remember not only that the Jews were first the people of God, but that the first Christians were also Jews. The Jews received no advantage from the Gentiles; but, on the contrary, the Gentiles have received much form the Jews, from whom the gospel sounded out - its first preachers being Jews, and of whom even Christ himself, as concerning the flesh, came to seek and save. The Gentile believers became the children of Abraham, and all the blessings they enjoy are in virtue of that relation."
      The relationship between Christians and Jews has not always been harmonious. In "Christian" countries Jews have often been persecuted. For example, in Portugal, Jewish children were forcibly taken from their parents and transported to the colonies, even into the nineteenth century. Persecution of the "Christ killers" in Nazi Germany was barbarous. We do well to recognize the spiritual heritage that is ours through Israel, and remind ourselves of Israel's inevitable acceptance of Jesus as messiah. Such should prompt the warmest of feelings toward those of the Jewish faith.
      Today, dispensational prophecy, focused on the emergence of the state of Israel, has also prompted positive attitudes. Yet, our attitude should not be driven by such wild speculation. The illegal and immoral dispossession and subjugation of the Palestinian people by the state of Israel is a blight on international affairs. It is this very injustice that has fired Islamic extremism. Our attitude toward those of the Jewish faith should not be driven by Zionist fervor, but rather by the knowledge of how much we owe to the children of Abraham, and in particular, Jesus, that one faithful Jew upon whom rests the salvation of both Jew and Gentile.

Discussion
      Why is there such hatred toward Jews, and what should be our attitude and why?


Notes

Textual notes   Abbreviations,   Bibliography
 
      Against the heresy of nomism (that a believer's standing before God is maintained and progressed by obedience to the law), Paul sets out in Romans to develop his thesis that the covenant faithfulness of God, evidenced in his saving activity, is appropriated by faith and not works of the law, 1:16-17. He establishes that sin is universal, whether for a lax Gentile believer, or a "righteous" Jewish believer, such that in the end, access to God's covenant fidelity, with its promised blessings (right-standing before God, reconciliation, sonship, the gift of the Spirit, right living and eternal salvation), rests on Christ's atoning work appropriated through faith and not submission to the Mosaic law. Yet, how can we be sure of these promises when the divine Abrahamic promises seem unfulfilled? Has not God abandoned national Israel? If God's covenant promises to Israel are unfulfilled, how can we be sure they will be fulfilled for us, the children of faith? Has not the Abrahamic covenant failed, 9:6a?
      Paul's argument is advanced in a clearly defined literary unit with an introduction, 9:1-5, and a conclusion, 11:33-36. In these three chapters Paul establishes that God's covenant promises have not failed since a remnant according to grace has facilitated a true Israel, 9:6-29, that national Israel's present condition of unbelief is due to its own pursuit of law-righteousness, 9:30-10:21, and that Israel's present state of unbelief is not final in that it does not annul God's promises, 11:1-36.
      Having established that Israel's rejection is not total, 11:1-10, Paul goes on to argue that neither is Israel's rejection final, v11-24.

v11
      iJna peswsin (piptw) aor. subj, act. "so as to fall beyond recovery" - that they might fall. The construction usually forms a purpose clause; "did they stumble in order that they might fall?" This probably misses the point Paul is making, although we than have to argue that Paul has not expressed himself well. Instead of "in order that" (implying that God has orchestrated their fall) we are best to go with a contemplated result (Sanday and Headlam), "with the result that." As for "fall", it is best taken as an irrevocable fall as in the NIV.
      paraptwmati (a atoV) "transgression" - sin, trespass. In this case, obviously Israel's rejection of the gospel.
      to parazhlwsai (parazhlow) aor. inf. "to make [Israel] envious" - to provoke to jealously. Articular infinitive forming a purpose clause. Paul uses Deut.32:21 from which to develop the idea that the incoming of the Gentiles will prompt israel to recognize what they have lost and so bring about repentance.

v12
      plhrwma (a atoV) "fullness" - There are a number of possible meanings in this context, but "the complete restoration of Israel" is probably what Paul means. If the conversion of the Gentiles is glorious, imagine how more glorious will be the conversion of Israel. Obviously this "fullness" or "completeness" is a representative whole, rather than all Jews.

v13
      ef oJson "Inasmuch as" - "In so far as I am apostle to the Gentiles I hope to promote the conversion of the Jews."

v14
      parazhlwsw (parazhlow) fut. "arouse ..... to envy" - I will/may make jealous, provoke to jealousy.
      tinas (tiV) - pro. "some" - a certain. Indicating Paul does not have false expectations regarding his own ministry. It is also possible that the conversion of some may achieve "fullness", again, of a representative whole.

v15
      hJ proslhmyis (iV ewV) "acceptance" - reception. The acceptance of someone into an association*. Here of Israel's reception into the community of believers.
      zwh ek nekrown "life from the dead" - life from dead ones. Paul is most likely referring to the resurrection of the dead on the last day. The incoming of the Jews, their "fullness", heralds the consumption of all things in the day of the resurrection of the dead.

v16
      to furama (a atoV) "the part of the dough" - batch, lump, lump of dough. The conversion of some Jews indicates that Israel, as a whole (still a representative whole), has a place in God's future intentions.

v17
      exeklasqhsan (ekklaw) aor. pas. "have been broken off" - were broken off. "Have been lopped off", Barclay.

v18
      mh katakaucw (katakaucaomai) imp. "do not boast over" - do not brag, triumph over. "Be on your guard not to boast of your superiority over those branches", Cassirer.

v20
      th/ apistia/ (a) "because of unbelief" - for unbelief. A dative of reference, "with respect to", or possibly interest, as NIV. Gentile boasting is foolish because salvation is by grace through faith, not by any effort, either by a Jew or a Gentile.

v21
      ouk efeisato (feidomai) aor. "did not spare" - To exempt from punishment or injury. "If God cut away those natural branches, couldn't he do the same to you?" CEV.

v22
      apotomian (a) "sternness" - severity, unbending rigor.

v24
      kata fusin (iV ewV) "wild by nature" - according to nature. The nature of something as the result of its natural development or condition*. Not as the NIV has it "you were cut out of an olive tree that is wild by nature", rather "you were cut from your wild olive tree." The Gentile branch was cut from a wild olive tree which it is by nature, and grafted into a cultivated olive tree. The point is that the Jews, although presently cut out, can easily be grafted back. It is easier to graft in cultivated stock than wild stock, just as it is easier to remove wild stork than cultivated stock.


[Printer icon]   A print friendly justified 10pt Times New Roman version sized to fit a 1 page A4, or 2 page A5 format.
 

[Pumpkin Cottage]
Pumpkin Cottage Ministry Resources
Lectionary Bible Studies and Sermons
www.lectionarystudies.com